?

Log in

No account? Create an account
scott pilgrim | the winstead effect

The Ongoing Scott Pilgrim Review: Part 2

A few observations, in no particular order:
  • I think I may have imagined the Bass Battle sounding like Queen's 'Brighton Rock', but I'm having a great time flicking between the two tracks trying to figure out if they sound even remotely similar.
  • I LOVE KIM PINE SFM.
  • That's twice I've seen this film now, and I'm pretty sure that both times, it hasn't been projected properly, because a) I'm sure I read something about aspect ratio shifts in a review somewhere and I haven't noticed any and b) Other Scott's intro box thingy always seems to get slightly cut off. I have a feeling I may not get to see it properly until it comes out on DVD.
  • There's this one line I can never quite remember, but it's when Nega Scott appears and it's one word away from 'This is something I have to do myself' and I always want Cera to say it in a Nicholas Angel voice and he never does.
  • I...didn't get what Roxy meant by 'you'll never be able to do this to her!' first time round, and now I feel hopelessly naive. Side note: I love that Scott and Ramona have an entire conversation in slow-mo.
  • I noticed for the first time the way that that 'Chaos Theatre' was spelt, and couldn't work out whether it was a deliberate mistake, or whether it was a genuine accident arising from having a largely British production team, or whether they used British spellings in Canada, and finally[info]robotinreallife came up with the bright idea of checking the spelling in the books, and it's the same. I did not know that Canadians use British spellings. You learn something new every day. (I know, I know; it is utterly ridiculous that I a) noticed and b) care.)
  • I love how there are no laughs and a few 'aww's when Scott breaks up with Knives, but then everyone cracks up when he sidles awkwardly off the edge of the screen.
  • I left the screening singing along to Sex Bob-Omb's 'Summertime' as it played over the end credits. This movie will destroy my non-existent credibility.
  • So many amazing background lines you can only hear if you're concentrating. I especially love Comeau's 'The first album is much better than the first album' as Scott enters the Chaos Theatre, followed the second time around by 'The comic book is much better than the movie'.
  • And finally, Seamus hasn't read the books but it was the second time he'd seen the movie. I showed him the beginning of vol. 1 on my ipod before we went in. He was amused to discover that the beginning is actually exactly the same.


In other news, this. I am basically reserving any kind of reaction until the level of Neil Gaiman's involvement is confirmed, but I will say that a) if he isn't involved at all then this is a horrible, HORRIBLE idea, and b) I think a TV show is a better idea than a film, if done properly. It's weird; I think it has the potential to work really well, but these characters are so distinct to me that I can't imagine any of them - particularly any of the Endless - being played by an actual human being, although I now want to attempt a casting picspam. Hmmm...

Comments

I bet it was a good day too
I'd say I'm approx 97% sure that I've done that multiple times

Christ am I Knives or something? I just legitimately clapped when I read "I do that all the time and it's usually to something really stupidly obscure like the commentary on the Shaun of the Dead DVD and everyone's just like 'whuh?'"
I quote commentaries all the freaking time and it's frustrating knowing people have no clue of the HILARITY I am referencing
I think my favourite line of SP had to be "Where's that from?" "MY OWN MIND!!" because that's how it is with my sister and me. We quote so much that sometimes it gets confusing and we assume things each other says are quotes we've forgotten but really it's just.. us saying stuff.

And yes; tone is key
You've got to like.. do the voices
And I'm not 100% on the exact phraseology so.. yeah. I can understand that explanations are necessary in this medium

I know! Canadians always seem so lovely and laid-back
Same with New Zealanders
Obviously in any places there are exceptions but the general consensus or whatever is nice, laid-back and.. stuff :)
Also both places look reeeeally pretty @_@

Heyyy speaking of your tags (you were) I just saw Adam and Joe residing alongside Edgar, Neil et al and when I clickety-clicked I saw you went to see one of Adam's Bug show thingies!
He came to Jersey a few weeks ago and we went to see his like... he was showing videos and stuff and it was so cute
I love him and you were right to be excited
I was VERY excited. Shaking and everything.
And while I'm on the subject of seeing cute amazing people (I.. am? ..is this getting old now? ...and did that need clarification?), I met Bryan Lee O'Malley at Forbidden Planet the other week at a signing
Ahhhhhh Bryan
Ahhhh Adam
Ahhhhhhhhh adorableness

And yay hoppity hops :B
Pahaaa, forget Knives, I've actually developed my own personal spazzy fangirl clap, because I'm a spaz. The best part is that there are a select few friends who won't even blink if I start clapping in excitement. Oh, and jsyk, if I ever write [flail]? Yeah nine times out of ten I'm actually flailing. I may, however, start using the patented Knives Chau OH MY GOD.

The reference I use which makes the least sense of any of them is 'Native American, Edgar, 'Red Indian' is an old, racist term', which is from the Spaced commentary and is utterly ridiculous because it is never, ever relevant. I cannot remember the last time I had a conversation about Native Americans. That one sentence just comes into my head every now and then. I really need to stop watching Spaced. (Actually, I gave it up for Lent, and that didn't really help.)

ADAMM. I'm going to see him again this Thursday, hurrah! I'm kinda lucky because he lives around here somewhere (my stalker skills have not developed enough to work out which area he lives in, but I'm working on it) and the only two places he does BUG on a regular basis are the BFI in London and the Playhouse in Norwich, and they're usually during the summer holidays so I'm home from uni and I get to gooo :) And I'm doing English, in Birmingham. I'm starting third year in less than a month, and I really don't want to, because third year is my final year and I DON'T WANT TO LEAVE :(

YOU MET BRYAN LEE O'MALLEY. YOU WOULD NOT BELIEVE HOW AMAZINGLY JEALOUS I AM, SERIOUSLY. Is he even more adorable in real life? I'm completely in love with his accent. (And his face.) If there isn't an Edgar/Bryan commentary on the Scott Pilgrim DVD I am actually going to cry.
HAHAAH I loved Knives's OH MY GOD
All the cartoon-y-ish things and expressions in the film were genius

Whenever I write HAHAHAHAHAHA or similar... yeah, I'm genuinely laughing.. or smiling.. I like.. would be laughing if I actually had the energy
And I've currently got a cold at the mo which weirdly makes me laugh a lot (probs the delirium setting in) so take it that I am actually laughing for realsies here
Espesh at the Native American thing ahahah love it
I often have one of Nick Frost's outtakes from Hot Fuzz in my head: "Have you ever fished a guy out of a bonfire and found it to be a trap?"
Also I regularly reference things in the bloody Dead Right commentary! How many people have seen that??!
Also in SP where Lucas Lee says "bucko" in his film on the TV that Wallace is watching it made me think of Dead Right where the murderer says "bucko" then Simon does an impression of him in the commentary..
HOW DO YOU EXPLAIN YOUR LAUGHTER AT THAT LINE WHEN THE REFERENCE IS THAT OBSCURE??!!

OH MY GOD *Knives-style ob-vi-oussslyy* I hadn't actually considered a Edgar/Bryan commentary!!! SO EXCITED!!!!!!!
I was thinking OH MY GOD the DVD extras are going to be IMMENSE and I naturally expected commentaries but... I didn't think about an Edgar and Bryan one!!!!

Photobucket

Yes, Sherlock it IS bloody Christmas! And the DVD had better be out before then or the suspense may well kill me!

ADAMMMMM YESSS
He so cute

Aw man that sucks
All my friends have left school and I'm repeating my last year (I was ill last year) so it's so lonely!
I can't wait to go to uni :)

WOOOOOO YESOUSY (that's like.. me saying "YES!" to jealousy)
YES he was insanely adorable I was like in awe of him and his adorableness
I want to be his friend or wife or whatever
Piss off, Hope! I know where you live and stuff! Ima force you to divorce (rhyme time)
HAHA joking HAHAHA *really false laughter to try to play down this lapse in sanity*
ADORABLE SHERLOCK IS ADORABLE

You know, I think I might actually have said "Have you ever fished a guy out of a bonfire and found it to be a trap?" in the middle of a perfectly normal conversation the other day. I have no idea what we were talking about. Luckily it was one of the few people I know who actually understands it ;) I think my personal favourite is 'Tim Messenger...foolishly confronted you at the village fete, after his own bollocks fell off.' Yarp.

Aw, good luck with your last year! Do you know what uni you want to go to/what you want to study? I'm now in the situation that a lot of my friends are in the year below me, so they're all still going to be studying when I leave. I'm actually considering trying to get a job in Birmingham just so I can still see them all. I'd miss them too much!

Yes, yesousy. That is the exact word for the emotion I am feeling right now, because it expresses jealousy but also I'm like 'YES!' for you that you got to meet him (just imagine me punching the air). I think I'd settle for friend, just because I like that Bryan and Hope are both comic artists, I think it's really cute. They're like the Brangelina of the comic book world, only better. And without the small African children. And I don't like Angelina Jolie. But still, COMIC POWER COUPLE IS AWESOME.
I'm glad you do it too! I need to re-watch
It's been a while
Need a refresher

I regularly greet people with "Hi-hi" a la Tim Messanger and say "bye" in the Liz "Bye bye bye bye bye bye" way.. but I suppose they're like some of the least obscure things to quote/use in (/at the end/beginning of) everyday conversation because people don't have to actually get that they're references!
Low risk.

Thanks! It's been going great so far :) I'd like to hopefully go to either Winchester (I instantly took a liking to it for the Shaun pub name! - then it has the absolute PERFECT course for me so it's like fate or something!) or Chichester (which, like Winchester is really beautiful and has an almost perfect course too) to do Creative Writing and Film Production. I'd like to be a writer/director a la Edgar ♥_♥

Yeah, I can imagine it being so hard thinking of leaving them. Sounds like a good idea to find somewhere close for a bit then you can all leave at the same time
Unless you find something amazing elsewhere of course but it's nice to ease yourself in kind of thing :)
What kind of job would you like ideally?

Yeah I do think Bryan and Hope must have a lovely relationship and of course I wouldn't like to break that up but ah.... IF NEEDS MUST
When proper grown ups ask me what kind of job I want I usually say 'I'm not sure, maybe something in publishing or journalism' but the truth is I want to be a writer. I think I always have. I should be the Simon to your Edgar, man. We'd be awesome. Creative Writing and Film Production sounds like an AMAZING course, btw. I've done a couple of modules in European Film while I've been at uni, and they were SO much fun. I should maybe have considered doing a joint honours course, but I never studied film at high school so I didn't know how much I loved it. But hey, I love my course, so it's all good :)
I've always wanted to be a writer too :)
Have you managed to do anything in your spare time?
I know I should keep practicing but it's hard to get into it!
I usually end up watching a film instead!
But it's good to get inspiration

Yeah, I've always loved films and they got me through being ill at home for so many years (since I was seven I've had stomach aches and got slowly pretty reclusive and depressed - getting a lot LOT better lately though!) but it wasn't until I saw Hot Fuzz a few years ago that I saw all the whip pans and got really excited about maybe making films of my own - realised it was something I'd really love to do :)
I still want to be an author too but writing for films and being able to sort of speak to people on such a big scale is so fantastic to me

And yes! I have a best friend called Laura who is a brilliant writer and my sister teetersslow is brilliant too - they're both hilarious - so I feel like we should create a massive writing team - you could join our gang!
Create a new show like Doctor Who with loads of writers, loads of input

What kind of European film have you looked at? I've only seen like Amelie and Paris Je T'aime - sadly very little!
omg I'm exactly the same! I always intend to start writing, but I get SO easily distracted, it's ridculous. I did NaNoWriMo last year and really loved it, though; I think I just need something to keep me motivated. I'll probably do it again this year.

I'm not actually sure when I became interested in film as a medium rather than just as a source of entertainment. It might have been when I started uni, possibly, although I think it happened fairly recently because I enjoyed last year's film module much more than I did the one before it.

I loved Paris Je T'aime! And if you like Amelie then you should definitely see A Very Long Engagement - it's directed by Jean-Pierre Jeunet and has Audrey Tatou and Gaspard Ulliel in and it's loovely. In terms of stuff I've studied...my favourite was probably the German film Run Lola Run. It's weird, I always just think of it as something I've studied and forget that I actually really love it. Also...uh, Salvador Dali's 'Un Chien Andalou' (crazy surrealists are crazy), Georges Melies's 'An Impossible Voyage' (not unlike a 1904 French version of the Mighty Boosh, I think a train gets eaten by the moon. Or was it the sun?), Schlondorff's 'Die Blechtrommel' (MORE DISTURBING THAN DALI, NOT EVEN JOKING). And, for some reason, Sally Potter's 'Orlando' and Ken Loach's 'The Wind that Shakes the Barley' which are both in English (ok, so I suppose England is in Europe, whatever). Those last two are both awesome, by the way. And 'The Wind that Shakes the Barley' has Cillian Murphy in it. Um, nom.

YES I WOULD LIKE TO BE IN YOUR WRITING GANG PLZ. IT SOUNDS AWESOME. :D

Oh and jsyk, I'm making this icon my dp, because IT IS JUST TOO DAMN CUTE. mmkay?
I'd love to do something like NaNoWriMo but I can never be bothered
My school is always super into the Commonwealth essay competition and I always mean to enter but never get round to it!

That's so weird! I was thinking about Run Lola Run the other day for the first time in ages because.. well I can't remember why (probably listening to The Kinks whilst jogging? IDK IDK.. well, defo not as I am way not active but.. yeah) but I've wanted to see it for ages because Edgar listed it as a favourite a couple of years ago
And I love Dali! I did a project on his life and work in primary school and we went to his museum thing in Spain last year - so good! Never seen any of his films though - look forward to recherching! Even if they are apparently... a little strange!

I very nearly ordered The Wind that Shakes the Barley a few weeks ago solely for Cillian perving purposes but didn't in the end as it looked a tad boring/depressing.. is it good?
I'll look out for the others too
I love films - I feel like even if they're bad you learn something from them!
Although I did watch Disco Pigs for Mr Murphy and that was one of the worst things I've ever seen
Still have no clue what the point in it was :/

YAY WE SHOULD THINK OF A NAME FOR OUR WRITING TROUPE

YAY! I love that icon/picture so s'all cool!
It's weird to be conversing with the same icon but also there is no such thing as too much Wright + Pegg so..
YEAH :D
Oh, let's just spam this whole comment thread with this one icon, it's already a Wright/Pegg-fest anyways :P

I know what you mean about NaNoWriMo, it does feel like a mammoth task, but once you get into it it's not so bad, and it's only 1667 word per day. Let me know if you feel like doing it this year; it's easier to stay motivated if you've got people nagging you to go write stuff, and even easier if you've got people doing it with you :)

EDGAR LIKES RUN LOLA RUN? I didn't even know that :D though now you mention it, I can kinda see why he would. You should definitely watch it. It doesn't look like it, but it always makes me feel happy. As for Dali...well, there's a famous scene involving a razor blade and an eyeball. And I suppose if you've studied his work, you already know about the ants thing. And...the dead donkey thing...

I LOVE The Wind that Shakes the Barley. I wouldn't say it's boring - I've seen it quite a few times - but yeah, it's depressing. It makes me feel ashamed of being English. Word of advice: don't watch that and Michael Collins in the same day, like I once did. Although, speaking of Cillian perving purposes, have you seen 28 Days Later? With the [cough] full-frontal nudity? (Um, it's also a really good film, honest?) Oh, and Sunshine, which is one of my favourite films EVER, and also has Chris Evans in it, yay! (That's actually hilarious.)

OMG I'M GONNA GO AND THINK OF A REALLY REALLY AWESOME NAME FOR OUR WRITING TROUPE. YEAH.